THE WEST
Where to Eat in Greeley Right Now: 13 Standout Spots
Birriería Doña María
By Rebecca Thompson | April 4, 2025
It’s the culinary scenes in Boulder and Denver that get all the attention here just east of the Rockies. But over the years Greeley, Colorado, has developed a collection of restaurants worthy of exploring. They dive deep into Greeley’s agricultural history (the sugar beet capital of the world!) and also take on the new trends that you’ll find in bigger cities. All of this is starring young stars born and bred here or arriving from far-flung spots, helping to make Greeley’s food scene one that just might surprise you. Here are the 13 best restaurants in Greeley right now.
1. Birriería Doña María
1825 9th St | Website | Instagram
It’s simple strip-mall exterior doesn’t give away what’s waiting inside, but walking in, you’ll be won over by the smell of something that’s been simmering since morning. The birria tacos come out crispy and greasy and completely necessary. Dip them in the consommé and you’ll see why there’s always someone waiting for a seat, even late on a Tuesday. There’s a huge menu, but don’t be scared away: everything from the nachos to the chicharron burrito are authentic, well done, and just maybe the best version of the dish you’ve had yet.
2. Lucky Fins
4530 Centerplace Dr | Website | Instagram
Lucky Fins is where Greeley gets its seafood fix, and trust me, it’s worth it. Located on Centerplace Drive, this spot offers dishes like Lobster Tots and Baja Fish Tacos that make you forget you’re hundreds of miles from the ocean. The sushi rolls are inventive and fresh—try the Spicy Tuna or Dragon Roll—and the vibe is as lively as the flavors.
3. Meeker's
919 7th St | Website | Instagram
The east side of Greeley will occasionally smell faintly of cattle, but inside Meeker’s, they’re plating bison meatloaf with mashed potatoes that could pass for your aunt’s if your aunt had a sous chef. It’s hotel-adjacent (connected to the DoubleTree) and so has to impress the corporate crowd. But chef Ron Jackson manages to sneak in real food—crispy fish and chips, a pork chop with actual sear, a cocktail menu that favors local distillers. Come for lunch, when the dining room is half full and the kitchen is still trying.
4. The Tavern
2918 67th Ave | Website | Instagram
Tucked away in a strip mall, The Tavern at St. Michael's Square doesn't scream for attention—but maybe it should. Chef Chad Young, a Greeley native, has been at the helm since its inception in 2010 and took ownership in 2012. The menu leans into comfort food with a twist; think meatloaf wrapped in bacon or a mac 'n' cheese that doesn't come from a box. The beer list is extensive enough to make you reconsider your usual domestic choice. It's the kind of place where the staff remembers your name and your drink order, which says a lot in a town this size.
5. Pellegrini Cucina Italiana
2400 17th St | Website | Instagram
Pellegrini's has had its share of hardships, including a fire in 2019 that could have spelled the end. Instead, they came back swinging, serving up Italian dishes that make you forget you're in Colorado. The handmade gnocchi in gorgonzola cream sauce is rich enough to make you loosen your belt a notch. The ambiance is intimate without trying too hard, making it a solid choice for date night or when you want to impress your in-laws.
6. Luna's Tacos & Tequila
806 9th St | Website | Instagram
Luna’s Tacos & Tequila isn’t just a taco joint; it’s an experience. Located downtown, this spot serves up scratch-made salsas and bold Mexican dishes that feel like they’ve been crafted by someone who truly loves food. Their cocktails are expertly mixed—pair one with their street tacos for maximum effect.
7. Taqueria Rancho Allegre
2729 8th Ave | Instagram
Rancho Alegre serves Latin cuisine that feels both hearty and refined—a rare combination indeed. Their homemade tamales are worth writing home about, while mole dishes bring depth to every bite. If you’re craving something authentic yet elevated, this spot delivers.
8. Santeramo's
1229 10th Ave | Website | Instagram
Santeramo's Pizza House & Italian Food is the kind of place where you feel like you’ve accidentally stumbled into someone’s family reunion—and somehow, they’re thrilled to have you. This central Greeley institution has been serving up Italian classics since 1962, and the recipes taste like they’ve been perfected over generations. The spaghetti and meatballs are a must, but honestly, anything here feels like comfort food done right.
9. Kingpot Korean BBQ & Hotpot
2118 35th Ave | Website
If you're in the mood to play with your food, Kingpot offers both Korean barbecue and hotpot options. Cooking your own meat at the table might not be everyone's idea of dining out, but here, it's part of the charm. The spicy beef bulgogi packs a punch, and the seafood hotpot is a treasure hunt of flavors. It's interactive dining that doesn't feel gimmicky.
10. Bowl Izakaya
1130 8th Avenue | Website
Bowl Izakaya brings a slice of Japan to Greeley, focusing on ramen and small plates. The tonkotsu ramen boasts a broth that's been simmered into creamy submission, with noodles that have just the right amount of chew. The minimalist decor keeps your attention on the food, which is exactly where it should be. It's a spot that could easily become a regular haunt.
11. Austin’s American Grill
1100 8th Ave | Website | Instagram
A mini regional chain with three locations, Austin’s promises a taste of authentic Colorado with its open-flame rotisserie. Think burgers as tall as your face, crispy-topped pot pies and, for brunch, breakfast burritos served handsomely sitting upright. On Fridays and Saturdays, there's a prime rib special, because Austin’s is the kind of place that’s popular among those who define dinner as a hefty plate of something pink in the middle.
12. Cancun Mexican Grill
5415 W 11th St | Website | Instagram
Cancun Mexican Grill & Cantina does Mexican staples right but also surprises with standout seafood options like shrimp enchiladas or fish tacos that burst with flavor. It’s lively without being overwhelming, making it great for families or groups looking for an authentic dining experience.
13. Pinocchio's
905 16th St | Website | Instagram
Pinocchio’s might be small in scale, but its Italian dishes pack big flavors. Creamy Alfredo pasta? Rich lasagna? Check and check. The intimate setting makes it feel like your own private slice of Italy right here in Greeley.
Rebecca Thompson has held many jobs: daily newspaper scribe; middle-school math teacher; and mom of a troublemaking tomboy. She’s searched her home state of Texas for the best brisket and tacos and will spend days debating the merits of combining the two.
